If you're new here, you may want to subscribe to my RSS feed. You can even subscribe by email! Thanks for visiting!
Sometimes it’s like this.
You love something so much that you can’t stop playing with it long after you know you should move on.
The ever-wonderful Kathy Sierra waxes deftly about this, the staying in the ‘comfort zone’ when you intuitively know you should be stretching. [As an aside, if you don’t read her blog at least once a week you’re an idiot. Period. Copy and paste her feed link into your rss aggregator/feed reader of choice now.]
Back to the story…
The same issue of ‘comfort zones and not moving on’ goes with blog editors (yes, my current hobby horse).
I’m writing this with RocketPost, because despite all of its crashingly obvious faults It still remains the best blog editor I have had the pleasure of working with (even though It has now developed a new‘ feature: It automatically capitalises the letter i when ever I type It, as you can see, But somehow leaves lower case I alone sometimes. I wonder If the developers have been watching that‘ Le’ts Sexy Englis’h video too much. And now I notice that It puts apostrophes In bizarre places even though I typed them correctly — sigh! And It has stopped converting a double hyphen into an em-dash…)
But I digress.
The reason I am sticking with RocketPost for this post (but would strongly recommend you stay well away from it) Is that I am mighty annoyed with the latest betas from Qumana and ecto.
One of my principle guiding philosophies with any web software Is that It has to be simple to install. My clients are not simpletons, but as compatriot Trevor Cook notes, not many of them are terribly web-savvy. So asking them to understand a philosophically new way of working with the internet (web 2.0) Is made extra difficult (as If It was’nt difficult enough) because they have to jump through multiple, confusing hoops to get anything to work.
… Post now being transferred to BlogJet for continued creation, so you can understand What I’m typing without your head exploding.
*******
Back to the Qumana and Ecto betas…
To get the latest Qumana beta to work I also have to download a java file. But I’m not told that during installation, nor given the opportunity to download it then. I am told that the installation has completed, not given the opportunity to have Qumana automatically open up (instead I get some stupid [in my eyes because there is no explanation of what it is or how to use it] large ‘Q’ in front of everything on my screen up in a corner. When I do finally go to Start / Programs and fire up Qumana it then gives me an error box telling me I’m missing a java file, pauses for long enough for me to wonder if it has crashed my computer, then fires up a browser window and wanders over to a website to allow me to download the file.
Eventually I get all of my downloading and installing done (“bloody great waste of time” says Mrs BetterComms and for once I’m on her side — why wasn’t it in the installation package?) and so I fire up Qumana. It asks me to give some info about my blog so that it can auto-connect to it.
But it fails to find my blog and then gives me an undecipherable error message that causes me to bang my head on the desk in frustration because I am not geek enough to understand what it is asking. What is inane about this is that the non-beta Qumana v2 which I have already gone through the hassle of configuring doesn’t have its settings transferred to the beta v3. I had enough trouble getting v2 connected.

And as if that weren’t enough, on top of that I cannot move or get rid of the annoying ‘Q’ at the top left of my screen, which stops me from being able to use, for example, my graphics tools because I cannot get to key tools to edit images. Grrrrrrr!
But BlogJet found and installed this blog easily – no fuss, just add login username and password and Bob is my proverbial mother’s brother. [“Bob’s your uncle” is a phrase the British use to indicate how simple something is; those of us who remember back to days of schoolboy Latin will also remember the phrase ‘QED’, which my personal musical hero* the sublime Thomas Dolby used to devastating effect in his Valley Girl song, “Airhead” — Tom sang, “quod erat demonstrandum, baby”, to which a background female vocalist, in Valley Girl accent, replied, “Oooh, you speak French!” ]
And Ecto is no better. I download the zip file from ecto’s bizarrely and unintuitively domain-named site (‘geek cool’ domain names are not cool for business folks who are struggling with real-life business issues and who see the internet as another waste of time), go to install it, and get told I need to download yet another file for the thing to work. And this download takes about an hour on a 128k connection — estimate that it takes about 2–3 hours on dialup.
[UPDATE: after taking an hour to download, I get an error message saying it can’t install some bit of code, but the exe file won’t let me try cranking up ecto again. Arrgghhh!!!]
No, “not happy Jan”, as we say here in Australia.
Sticking with BlogJet for the moment, but wishing that RocketPost will come back from the grave…
And fellow traveller on this blog editor journey, Dave Briggs, has eruditely suggested that, piggybacking on the success of the International Association of Nobodies, we start a new association: Blogger’s Off Line League Of Content Kreation Systems.
As Dave himself says,
Spelling ‘creation’ with a ‘k’ will certainly add to our appeal to the kidz, though the acronym of this putative campaign may cause some difficulties
I wholeheartedly concur with his nomenclative suggestion, noting that the ‘k’ in ‘kreation’ will not only appeal to the kidz (always a good thing to do), but also to the radical and ‘young at heart’ of all of we more mature and emotionally stable members of the community.
Anyone care to create a logo?
* disinterested readers may be bored to note that I used to write and record my own songs, a friend once flatteringly suggesting I was an Australian ‘Thomas Dolby’. Indeed, it was to pursue a career as a songwriter, and endure fame, fortune and lashings of ginger beer, that I moved to England. Failing to make a dent in the recording careers of Sting, George Michael, et al., I ended up reading for a first degree in Applied Psychology and Sociology. As one normally does in such circumstances.
back to the story…



{ 4 trackbacks }
{ 12 comments… read them below or add one }
Wow - that headline had me worried for a minute
I thought you might have started working ‘blue’ Lee.
Never underestimate the power of a great headline, Paull.
Lee - pleased that my campaign idea has struck a chord with you. It’s time these so-called offline blog editor developers actually gave us a tool that we actually want!
I have now designed the logo, which I am sure you will agree strikes exactly the right tone for the campaign. I mean, who wouldn’t want a t-shirt with a professional design like that on it? Eh? Oh.
Am currently planning “The Million Bollock March” where all 500,000 of us (give or take the odd woman or eunuch) invade the offices of RocketPost, Qumana and Blogjet just as soon as we find out where they are.
Hi Dave,
Probably would be good to create a logo a LEEEEETLE less descriptive, something more esoteric and tangental. Give it a go…
Oh boy, Lee, what a fiasco! Agree wholeheartedly with you re RocketPost. Don’t touch it with a barge pole. It’s a huge scam. I’m actually surprised you got it working.
Interesting reading how you describe ecto for Windows. I’ve been using ecto since 2004 and have a true love/hate relationship with it. The hate in areas such as you describe. The love because it works. Well, I refer to release versions especially version 1.8.8. The betas really are for testing only. I’m testing ecto 2 RC3 at the moment. Very close to final. I think this will be the one that gets pretty close to many of the things you outlined in your earlier wishlist post. Not everything, but close (RocketPost could have been the wishlist everything). Qumana 3 is still beta and I’ve also experienced the disappearing post frustration (which I reported to Qumana). A big show-stopper, in my view. Not heard of that happening with release version 2, though. Not good.
So the market’s still wide open for someone to offer a blog management and editing tool that works across different blog platforms and which fulfills most of the wishes. I wonder what we’ll see in the final Microsoft Office 12 when it appears?
I have tried again…
Thanks for the input, Neville.
I had completely forgotten about Office12… Hmmmm - since Office 11 adds horrific non-compliant code to its html output I guess I didn’t even bring it into the equation. But now that Microsoft is trying its hardest to be a ‘friend’ to the internet rather than a ‘huge pest’, it will be interesting to see how compliant the code from Office12 will be.
If they release blog-compatible software (which could be why they are delaying the release of O12 and Vista, to make sure it actually works), then they could wipe out all the minnows in one fell swoop (which would be a superb marketing achievement).
After all, they usurped Netscape through brilliant marketing strategy and tactics to bring Internet Explorer to the marketplace. They could easily take that learning and apply it to blog editing software.
Oh Neville…. methinks you have hit on a bit of a meme-fest with that one… Let me chew on it overnight (I’m currently 1.5 bottles into the restorative bubbly and it’s 10 at night) and see what comes out of my BLOGJET blog editor in the morning…)
Ta, mate!
And its interesting how NONE of the editor folks have joined the discussion, yet one must feel that their products have entered into Technorati ego searches by now…
Come on, developers — tell us what you are up to. Why do your products so suck? Why do they not meet our desires? What are you doing about it? Why have we not heard from RocketPost for a while, inspite of the fact they had the very best editor for AGES???
The notion of a blogging editor being part of Office 12 is an intriguing one. However, I haven’t heard any rumours of it, and I doubt it would come close to what we have been outlining here. For example, would Microsoft really provide a tool that would interact with PHP and MySQL - two direct competitors to its own products? What would be more likely is that MS would produce there own blogging platform based on SQL Servier and .Net and make you use that.
I don’t use Microsoft software on my home PC at all - other than Win XP and that might be going soon - but I do appreciate that an awful lot of companies and organisations do. Now, if blog posting and management was built into Outlook, along with a NewsGator style RSS reader plug-in, using a .Net blogging platform then that might be a setup that would be enough to convince the most sceptical of CEOs that blogging is a Good Thing.
Absolutely, Dave. Bring .net into Outlook and auto rss feeds and blogging (i.e. input and output from the same tool) and you have a winner…
Hi Lee, it’s me again. We’ll definitely work on getting the download requirements better documented and work on a better installer for the Java dedection.
For the DropPad (that’s the square thing) you should be able to move it (I like the lower left corner myself) … I will follow up with the developer about the moving problem (we’ll probably need to contact you directly for that).
I like your suggestion of moving over v2 settings, I can’t promise we’ll have a solution, but we know that it’s important and we would like to get something working.
We appreciate all your feedback. We really do. Love to know more about why you WP blog wasn’t detected … we try to auto-detect as many blogs as possible.
So … one blog editor company has entered the fray. Let me have your comments and feedback.
Hey (again) Tris — really appreciate your comments. As you can probably tell from my latest few posts, Zoundry has taken the BetterComms Towers crew by surprise, partly because they meet many of the ‘wish list’ features (or have explained why they can’t — e.g. server-side issues with WordPress), and partly because they installed and found one of my blogs so easily. I have yet to try using it one more than one of my blogs (that’s tomorrow’s experiment, once I have reclaimed those lost hours of productivity).
I’m not trying to set up a ‘contest’ here between yourselves and Zoundry (and it’s interesting that neither the ecto or RocketPost folks have entered the conversation), but I am genuinely interested in helping create a ‘works first time, every time’ tool that I can recommend to my business clients (who don’t have a lot of time to spare and who mostly see the internet as a waste of time and productivity anyway).
Thanks again for being a great part of this conversation — much appreciated.